Get the latest news to your email inbox FREE!

REGISTER

Get the latest news to your email inbox FREE!

REGISTER
HomeYour LettersAssassination of Osama Bin Laden

Assassination of Osama Bin Laden

So 86 per cent of Americans approved of the assassination of Osama Bin Laden.
The only advantage from this reprehensible act is, possibly, electoral votes for President Obama.
Putting aside Osama Bin Laden, along with fanatical extremists of any religion who act equally as dangerously and crazily, they are still entitled to a civilised trial in a regular Court of Law.
In the first instance the USA’s action, in not respecting another nation’s sovereignty is nothing unusua. This is something they do regularly, when assassinating, kidnapping, “Renditioning”, or invading.
These activities are not confined to America. Israel, remember France’s Greenpeace incursion in NZ? The USA was, quite rightly, incensed at the attack on their soil in 9/11, but indignantly and hypocritically have no qualms when using the same actions themselves.
Bin Laden, evidently unarmed, was not given an opportunity to surrender to an overwhelmingly superior armed force invading his bedroom.
Initially it was claimed his murdered wife was used as a human shield.
It is more likely that she threw herself in front of her husband to protect him, in the mistaken belief soldiers wouldn’t shoot an unarmed woman. She was so wrong; it has never stopped other unwarranted killings of unarmed innocents.  Democracy is best summarised by: “A nation governed for the people, by an administration which accords with, and is regulated by established Laws and Courts”. The summary execution of Bin Laden is in stark contrast to this basic tenet.
Not only will this action not stop the Al Quaeda Movement, in my opinion, it will garner new, and willing, recruits to the medieval philosophies of these fanatics. If ever there was an action that was designed to further exacerbate the contempt for the hypocritical standards adopted by the USA (and others) to promote “democracy” then this was it.
It hasn’t surprised me. The USA is often viewed as being a nation of violence and revenge. Is it any wonder that many Americans believe that justice comes from owning a bigger and better gun, with the willingness to use it, when their own government pursues the same ideology? The cheering, exuberance and blood lust shown, concomitant with the leader’s own examples and encouragement, is reminiscent of the public executions in Europe’s not so glorious past of public executions, and the still inglorious days of Saudi Arabia, amongst others, who still maintain this medieval mindset. All this shows that education for the masses hasn’t been very successful in advancing neither intellectual comprehension, nor compassion.
Once again the biggest disappointment is in the blanket acceptance by Australia’s two political leaders for this illegal and undemocratic episode. True friends are those with whom you can disagree, in this instance the acquiescence is just another example of obsequious sycophancy. “All the way with the USA” or the American “My way or you can’t play”.
Yes Bin Laden, and his actions, was evil. That is not an excuse for us to be just as bad.
Tom Edgar

Digital Edition
Subscribe

Get an all ACCESS PASS to the News and your Digital Edition with an online subscription

Residents hoping Cherrabah rejection sends clear message

Elbow Valley residents are hoping the Southern Downs council’s overwhelming rejection of a controversial water bottling facility at Cherrabah Resort sends a clear message...
More News

Three teams in semis hunt

Souths, Valleys and RSL are all still in the race for the Stanthorpe and District Cricket semi final with just one round to go...

Warwick Show returns for 2026

The annual Spano’s IGA Warwick Show is returning to the Warwick Showgrounds from Friday, 10 March to Sunday, 22 March, promising a weekend of...

Festival icon Johnny Crunch returns

Johnny Crunch, also known as Jonno Apple, will again lead the 2026 Apple and Grape harvest festival parade. The nearly 4 metre high fibreglass...

Stanthorpe swimmers excel at Pittsworth

A team of eight swimmers from Stanthorpe Swimming Club headed to Pittsworth on Sunday for the Pittsworth Piranhas long course swim meet. “There...

Forgotten Dalveen veterans finally recognised

Nineteen World War One veterans have been added to the Dalveen Honour Board after over a century of being unnamed and unrecognised in the...

Grassroots push to stop gendered violence before it starts

Advocates will spell out the 12 actions community members can take to prevent violence against women at two free workshops in Warwick next week. The...

Sovereign Animals search for first cup

Sovereign Animals are through to their first ever Warwick Cricket Condamine Cup grand final following a gutsy four-wicket win over Redbacks at Slade Park...

GALLERY: Killarney show delivers big weekend

Small in size but big in spirit, this year’s Killarney Show delivered the goods. Considered one of the smaller agricultural shows on the Darling Downs,...

Historic win for Stanthorpe

A solid 61 not out from Stanthorpe’s leading run-maker Adam Bonner has helped put the coveted Slade Shield back on the wall in the...

Renewed scrutiny over controversial water licence

Despite persistent community opposition, Queensland Water Minister Ann Leahy has so far resisted making a call on whether to call-in and reassess the controversial...